META-EVALUATION OF THE PROJECT EVALUATIONS – CONSULTANT

Consultant duration: December 2026 – January 2027

I. INTRODUCTION

Educo is a development cooperation and humanitarian action NGO with more than 30 years of experience working for children, committed to a world where children and adolescents fully enjoy their rights and a life of dignity. This vision guides our work with 

children, adolescents, and their environments, with the aim of contributing to the construction of fairer, more equitable and sustainable societies that guarantee their rights and comprehensive wellbeing. 

In response to evolving global and local challenges affecting children and adolescents, Educo has developed its 2026-2030 Global Programmatic Framework (GPF), which establishes the organization’s strategic priorities and programmatic directions. Aligned with the GPF, Educo Philippines has developed its 2026-2030 Country Programmatic Framework (CPF), which outlines the country’s strategic program focus, and priorities based on the specific needs, vulnerabilities, and opportunities identified within the Philippine context. 

As part of Educo Philippines’ commitment to accountability, learning, evidence generation, and adaptive programming, various evaluations, reviews, assessments, studies, and learning exercises will be conducted throughout the CPF implementation period. To strengthen evaluation quality, accountability, and organizational learning, Educo Philippines intends to undertake a Meta-Evaluation of completed evaluations and assessment processes.  

The meta-evaluation will review the quality, rigor, utility, credibility, and contribution of completed evaluations, while identifying lessons and recommendations to improve future evaluation practice, evidence generation, and decision-making processes. 

II. OBJECTIVES OF THE EVALUATION

The meta-evaluation aims to assess and synthesize the evidence generated through project evaluations conducted under Educo Philippines’ programs between 2021 and 2026, while examining the methodological quality, credibility, utility, and contribution of these evaluations to organizational learning, accountability, and decision-making. 

Specifically, the following are the objectives of the review: 

  1. Assess the scope, design, and methodologies of the project evaluations and their alignment with OECD-DAC Standards. 
  2. Analyze and synthesize evidence across projects to identify common results, cross-cutting themes, recurring implementation challenges, emerging trends, and evidence gaps. 
  3. Generate actionable recommendations to strengthen future evaluation, design, implementation, reporting, utilization, and learning systems. 

      III. SCOPE OF WORK

      The meta-evaluation will review fourteen (14) End-of-Project Evaluations conducted between 2021 and 2026 across Educo Philippines’ thematic areas, including Child Protection, Child Participation, Education, and Humanitarian Action.  

      The meta-evaluation identifies common trends, cross-cutting findings, good practices, recurring challenges, and evidence gaps across the areas of operation and thematic areas. The exercise will involve a comprehensive review and analysis of these evaluations to assess the quality, credibility, and robustness of their methodologies, findings, and conclusions. It will also examine the extent to which the evaluations provide reliable evidence on program performance, effectiveness, efficiency, sustainability, and impact.  

      Please see Annex 1 for the project information to be covered by the review.  

      IV. METHODOLOGY OF THE EVALUATION

      The meta evaluation will be guided by the OECD criteria of evaluation (relevance, effectiveness, efficiency, sustainability, and impact).  

      The evaluation will be guided by these TOR and an Inception Report to be produced by the selected consultant. The evaluation will consist of desk-based analysis only, and no fieldwork is anticipated, although Educo partners could be consulted. 

      The evaluation will involve: 

      • Document review: the main data collection method will be a document review, which includes the review of guidelines and notes on conducting evaluations, evaluation reports and project completion reports) and other Educo strategic documents, such as GPF, CPC, Country Organizational Plan and Annual Operational Plan. 

      V. TIMELINE AND EVALUATION DELIVERABLES

      Educo will hire an independent external contractor to conduct the evaluation, ensuring objectivity and impartiality. The contractor will be responsible for preparing an evaluation plan, along with methodologies and tools. Educo will review all results to ensure consensus and agreement before finalizing the evaluation report. 

      The consultancy will cover a period between December 2026 and January 2027 for a total of 60 days. The following is a tentative schedule: 

      Phase Activity Schedules 
      Preparation and design  Hiring of a contractor Third week of November 2026 
      Orientation on Educo Policies and Procedures 1st  week of December 2026 
      Preparation and submission of evaluation or work plan, evaluation tools or inception report 1st  week of December 2026 
      Inception meeting with Educo Staff 2nd week of December 2026 
      Review Assessment phase: review of evaluation reports, interviews and analysis  3rd to 4th Week of December 2026 
      Reporting Draft the meta-evaluation report 5 Fourth week of August 1st week of January 2027 
      Present the Initial Report to the Educo Staff 2nd Week of January 2027 
      Review of the draft report by Educo Staff  2nd to 3rd Week of Januaru 2027 
      Presentation of the Report with PowerPoint Presentation  1st to 2nd Week of January 2027 
      Submit the Final Report and Executive Summary (Five Pages) 2nd to 3rd Week of January 2027 

      VI. EVALUATION COMPLETION DEADLINES AND DELIVERABLES

      The consultant is expected to deliver the following products: 

      The consultant shall deliver: 

      • Inception Report, including methodology, workplan, assessment framework, and tools. 
      • Meta-Evaluation Quality Assessment Matrix. 
      • Evidence Synthesis Matrix. 
      • Summary of Key Informant Interviews and Surveys (if applicable). 
      • Draft Meta-Evaluation Report. 
      • Validation Presentation. 
      • Final Meta-Evaluation Report. 
      • Executive Summary (maximum 5 pages). 
      • PowerPoint Presentation of findings and recommendations. 

      VII. EVALUATION REPORT STRUCTURE AND SUBMISSION

      • Executive Summary  
      • Introduction  
      • Background and Context  
      • Purpose and Objectives  
      • Scope and Methodology  
      • Meta-Evaluation Quality Assessment Findings  
      • Portfolio-Level Evidence Synthesis  
      • Analysis of Child Rights, Gender, Inclusion and Safeguarding  
      • Evaluation Utilization and Organizational Learning  
      • Cross-Cutting Findings, Good Practices and Innovations 
      • Evidence Gaps  
      • Conclusions  
      • Strategic and Actionable Recommendations  
      • Annexes  
        • Evaluation Rating Matrix 
        • Documents Reviewed 
        • Interview List 
        • Assessment Tools 

      VIII. BUDGET

      The total budget for this meta-evaluation is Php200-250,000.00, nclusive of all professional fees, travel expenses, accommodation, communication costs, data collection expenses, taxes, and other costs necessary to complete the assignment.  

      IX. EVALUATOR SPECIFICATION

      Qualifications: 

      Educational Qualifications: 

      • Bachelor’s Degree in a relevant field (e.g. social sciences, development studies, international development, or any related field). 
      • Master’s Degree (optional but often preferred), specialized areas such as project management, evaluation, monitoring and evaluation (M&E), or other relevant fields. 

      Relevant Experience: 

      • Project Management Experience: Hands-on experience in managing or working on projects, particularly those that are being evaluated. This could include any roles related to project management, specifically on MEAL. 
      • Evaluation Experience: With extensive work experience in conducting evaluations, especially End of Project (EoP) evaluations. Familiarity with methodologies, tools, and best practices for evaluating a project’s success, challenges, and impact. 
      • Sector-Specific Expertise: Child rights and well-being, governance, child protection, gender studies/evaluations, or similar fields are preferred 

      Skills and Competencies: 

      • Analytical Skills: Ability to analyze data and assess project outcomes, impacts, sustainability, and alignment with objectives. 
      • Research and Evaluation Skills: Proficiency in qualitative and quantitative research methods, including designing evaluation frameworks and tools like surveys, interviews, and focus groups. 
      • Report Writing: Strong skills in preparing detailed reports, presentations, summarizing findings, conclusions, and recommendations. 
      • Stakeholder Engagement: proven capacity to collaborate effectively with local communities, civil society partners, and government stakeholders in participatory evaluation processes. 

      Knowledge of Evaluation Standards and Frameworks: 

      • Familiarity with international standards for evaluations, such as the OECD-DAC criteria (Relevance, Effectiveness, Efficiency, Impact, Sustainability). 
      • Commitment to ethical research and evaluation practices, including child safeguarding, informed consent, data protection, and respect for participant confidentiality. 

      X. EVALUATION, AUTHORSHIP, AND PUBLICATION PREMISES

      • Anonymity and confidentiality: The evaluator must respect the right of individuals to provide information by ensuring that sensitive data cannot be traced to its source. 
      • Honesty and Integrity: The evaluator must accurately represent their level of knowledge and skills, work only within the limits of their professional abilities for the evaluation, accurately present their procedures, data and findings and be responsible in highlighting concerns mentioned or not un the TOR, if necessary, to obtain a more complete result.  The evaluator must be sensitive to the beliefs, manners and customs of the social and cultural environments in which they work. 
      • Independence: The evaluator must ensure that they are not unduly influenced by the views or statements of any actors involved and guarantee his independence and objectivity in the analysis of the data and information collected. 
      • Accountability: The evaluator is accountable for the quality completion of the evaluation deliverables within the timeframe and budget agreed.  In the event that any changes to the evaluation plan or any risks to the successful completion of the evaluation, the evaluator shall give Educo early notice. 
      • Intellectual property: During the assignment or at any time after the expiration or termination of the contract, the evaluation team may not disclose to any person or make use of any confidential information obtained during the course of this contract relating to the local partner organization and/or Educo, participants or any other person connected with the process.  The rights of the author and the publication of the documents produced by the evaluation team according to this agreement belong to Educo. 
      • Child Safeguarding Policy and Code of conduct: The contractor commits to upholding ethical and responsible behavior in the delivery of their activity, with the utmost respect and fulfillment of Educo’s policies, codes and procedures; and accepts that non-fulfilment will lead to the termination of the contract with Educo, regardless of the any type of consequence or responsibility that could result from this.  

      XI. INSTRUCTIONS TO INTERESTED PARTIES 

        Please submit your proposal to [email protected] not later than November 22, 2026. Proposals should contain the following:  

        • Curriculum Vitae of the Evaluation Team addressing the specifications mentioned 
        • Technical proposal  
        • Financial proposal to carry out the assignment 

        Annex 1: Projects with Evaluation Covered by the Project 

        PROJECT PROJECT DURATION THEMATIC AREA BUDGET COVERED AREAS IMPLEMENTATION TYPE EVALUATION TYPE 
        Project SAFE: Strengthening 
        Accountability For Girls And Boys In Educo Partner Schools And Communities 
        01/03/2018 – 31/05/2021 Humanitian Action USD 659,820 (32,499,434.10) Bato, Camarines Sur Nabua, Camarines Sur Libon, Albay Direct Implementation External End of Project Evaluation 
        Project SAGIP (Strengthening Accountability in Governance towards Ending Child Labor by Promoting Rights and Providing Socio-Economic Support)  01/01/2021 – 30/09/2023 CHILD PROTECTION 7,494,604.96 Municipalities of Caramoran, Catanduanes, Manito, Albay, and Pilar, Sorsogon. Direct Implementation External End of Project Evaluation 
        Project (CoP-CFLG)Establishing enhanced communities of practice in child-friendly local governance and social accountability (CoP-CFLG) 01/07/2021 – 30/11/2023 Child Participation 17,252,077.10 Municipality of Caramoran Catanduanes, Manito Albay, Castilla, Pilar, Donsol Sorsogon, and Zamboanga City. Direct Implementation External End of Project Evaluation 
        Project PACES II: Partnership for access to quality early childhood care and education services – PACES II 16/01/2021 – 31/12/2023 Education 10,917,200.00 Municipality of Manito, Castilla, Pilar, Donsol, Catanduanes  Direct Implementation External End of Project Evaluation 
        KCiE Project: Keeping children in-school, bringing back to education the out-of-school 01/01/2021 – 31/12/2023 Education 11,112,503.08 Municipalities of Donsol, Pilar and Castilla in Sorsogon, Municipality of Manito in Albay and Municipality of Caramoran in Catanduanes   Direct Implementation External End of Project Evaluation 
        Project PACES III Partnership for Access to quality early Child Care and Education Services – PACES III 01/09/2022 – 31/12/2024 Education 10,603,200.00 Municipalities of Castilla, Donsol, and Pilar in Sorsogon; municipality of Manito in Albay; and the Municipality of Caramoran in Catanduanes. Direct Implementation Internal End of Project Evaluation 
        Project ChildGov: Social Innovation for Mainstreaming Child Rights in Gov 01/09/2022 – 31/08/2025 Child Participation 22,636,950.00 Municipalities of Castilla, Donsol, and Pilar in Sorsogon; municipality of Manito in Albay; and the Municipality of Caramoran in Catanduanes.  Direct Implementation External End of Project Evaluation 
        Children as Agents of Social Transformation (CAST) 01/09/2022 – 31/08/2025 Child Participation 16,376,300.00 Municipalities of Castilla, Donsol, and Pilar in Sorsogon; municipality of Manito in Albay; and the Municipality of Caramoran in Catanduanes. Direct Implementation  External End of Project Evaluation 
        Project STEPS: Systematic Approach to Engage Children in their Protection and Safe and Protective Environment 01/09/2022 – 31/08/2025 Child Protection 11,637,950.00 Municipalities of Castilla, Donsol, and Pilar in Sorsogon; municipality of Manito in Albay; and the Municipality of Caramoran in Catanduanes.  Direct Implementation  External End of Project Evaluation 
        Project WE LEAP Empoderar a mujeres en participación y acceso a recursos económicos a través de mecanismos de protección con enfoque de género en Filipinas 17/02/2022 – 16/07/2024 CHILD PROTECTION EUR 502,173.60 Municipalities of Camalig and Manito Indirect/LPO Implementation –0 MIDAS and BCCD External End of Project Evaluation 
        Project UPGRADE – Upgrading the Literacy of Non Readers of primary Graders through Play, Music, and Movement 01/02/2025 – 30/04/2026 Education 6,397,907.50 Manito, Albay; Castilla and Donsol, Sorsogon Indirect/LPO Implementation – Federation of Association for Communities and Children’sEmpowerment Inc. (FACE Inc.)   External End of Project Evaluation 
        Project RECEIVE (Resilient Education in Emergencies for Children’s Empowerment and Vital Education) 01/03/2025 – 31/03/2026 Humanitarian Action 7,076,285.62 Manito, Albay; Castilla and Donsol, Sorsogon  Indirect/LPO Implementation – Federation of Association for Communities and Children’sEmpowerment Inc. (FACE Inc.)   External End of Project Evaluation 
        Child Led Advocacy Academy Project 01/07/2024 – 31/05/2026 Child Participation 16,633,914.52 Municipalities of Pilar, Castilla, Donsol, Manito and Caramoran Indirect/LPO Implementation – ChildFund Philippines  External End of Project Evaluation 
        Project SAGIP 2: Strengthening Accountability in Governance towards Ending Child Labor by Promoting Rights and Providing Socio-Economic Support 01/07/2024 – 31/05/2026 Child Protection 12,858,060.15 Municipalities of Pilar, Manito and Caramoran Indirect/LPO Implementation – Bicol Center for Community Development (BCCD)  External End of Project Evaluation